Broad Strokes with Fine Lines: A Dance between Details and the Big Picture in Mystery Writing

modern painting in bright colors with fine lines and broad strokes

You know the saying, “You can’t see the forest for the trees.”  It applies to story writing as well. You can get trapped in the details and lose the plot.

Explore the fine balance—balancing even the minute details with your grand storyline. 

Every mystery author knows the value of every clue, every hint, every seemingly insignificant detail; after all, they give life to the enchanting worlds you create. But just as important is making sure these details contribute to and don’t detract from your main plot—the big picture. 

This discussion’s heart is the balance between the detail and the big picture. This exploration grips your readers from the start and carries them, unhurried but captivated, into the arms of the thrilling conclusion. 

Understanding the Big Picture

In mystery writing, the ‘big picture’ refers to the overarching storyline or main plot that guides the progression of your novel. This includes the central conflict, the characters, their motivations, and the projected resolution. 

The big picture sets the stage, dictates the movement of the plot, and oversees the interplay of individual chapters and scenes. It’s what your readers are ultimately trying to figure out through the clues you provide, and it’s what the climax and resolution of your mystery novel should address.

The big picture’s importance in a mystery novel cannot be overstated. It is the compass guiding your narrative development and influencing your characters’ decisions. Defining your big picture clearly before delving into intricate detail work is crucial. This ensures that your narrative maintains a cohesive and engaging flow throughout.

There’s a balance to consider here. While the big picture shapes the overall narrative, it also draws from the smaller moments within your story, including individual scenes and character interactions. 

Understanding the big picture is not about preserving a singular, unchanging plot. Instead, it’s about creating a strong, adaptable narrative blueprint to accommodate and integrate the fine details that make your mystery novel genuinely compelling.

Emphasizing Details

Mystery writing thrives on the interplay of details within a narrative. These details—the small, perhaps subtle elements that may initially seem trivial—play a hugely significant role in constructing a compelling mystery. The utility of details lies in their capacity to introduce clues, indicate red herrings, create suspense, or even fabricate an atmospheric setting that shapes the readers’ experience.

You plant seeds that grow into plot developments later in the story through the character’s observations, dialogue, the objects they interact with, or even the setting. These details often enhance the reader’s engagement, encouraging them to pay close attention, form theories, and actively uncover the mystery at hand.

While details are integral to your narrative, they should be in collaboration with your story from its central track. The challenge, then, is to ensure every detail serves the big picture, however minor it may seem. 

This might seem daunting—juggling myriad details while ensuring they all contribute to the larger plot. But when executed efficaciously, it greatly enhances the depth and intrigue of your mystery novel, making it a captivating read. 

To illustrate this, let’s take a look at some representative examples from esteemed and successful mystery novels that spark readers’ curiosity through meticulous detail, all while propelling the main plot forward.

Harmonizing the Big Picture and Details

The crux of effective mystery writing lies in your ability to harmonize the details and the big picture, but achieving this balance may take time. Here, we’ll discuss strategies that can guide you in ensuring that all these numerous and intricate details contribute effectively to your overarching plot.

1. Establish Consistency: Consistency is key in mystery writing. Create a story universe where the details and the big picture conform to the same rules. All clues, red herrings, or hints—no matter how big or small—should be part of this universe and help construct the mystery.

2. Develop Details to Drive the Plot: Consider its relevance to the broader narrative when introducing a detail. Does it push the plot forward or contribute to developing your characters or themes? If the answer is negative, you should reconsider its inclusion or rework its presentation.

3. Use Foreshadowing: This is a powerful tool when used judiciously. The details you drop early in your narrative could have significant implications later on, thus contributing to the big picture. Foreshadowing is an excellent method of ensuring your details and overarching plot are entwined.

4. Aiming for Coherence: Your details mustn’t contradict the big picture. Coherence throughout a mystery novel is essential to avoid confusing or misleading your reader unintentionally.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

While attempting to harmonize details and the big picture in your mystery novel, you may encounter pitfalls that affect the narrative’s effectiveness. Here are some common mistakes to keep an eye out for and strategies to help you navigate them:

1. Overstuffing Your Story With Details: While rich details can make your narrative more engaging, an overload can confuse readers, making it harder for them to follow the main plot. Ensure that every detail you include is relevant and contributes to the story you’re trying to tell. 

2. Neglecting the Big Picture: In an attempt to craft engaging details, you might diverge from the main plot, but remember that this can prove counterproductive. Regularly revisit your big picture to ensure you always move toward the main mystery’s resolution.

3. Inconsistencies Between the Details and the Big Picture: This typically happens when you introduce details at odds with the overarching storyline. To avoid this, always cross-check your details with the central plot to maintain narrative integrity.

4. Leaving Plot Holes: Plot holes often occur when an introduced detail is not tied up or addressed later in the story. As the writer, it’s crucial to be aware of every loose end and work towards tying them up logically.

5. Introducing Irrelevant Red Herrings: While red herrings can add intrigue to your story if they don’t connect to your narrative, they can detract from the main plot and confuse your reader. Balance their use and ensure they contribute to the overall mystery.

Avoiding these common mistakes requires diligence and frequent self-review throughout the writing process. A well-crafted mystery delights in details, but it also maintains a clear and traceable line to the big picture. As the author, it is your job to steer your narrative down this intriguing and suspenseful path carefully.

Mastering the Intricate Dance: Final Thoughts on Balancing Details and the Big Picture in Mystery Writing

The dance between the big picture and the dense details within mystery writing is intricate and graceful. The big picture sets the stage for your grand narrative, dictating your mystery’s overall course and eventual resolution. On the other hand, each meticulously crafted detail brings life to this broader context, enhancing the reader’s engagement and pushing your plot forward.

However, achieving this harmony could be a daunting prospect. Striving for the right balance and ensuring each detail plays its part while always keeping sight of the big picture is a challenging task. Nevertheless, it fashions a compelling and engrossing mystery that resonates with readers when performed proficiently.

I encourage you to experiment, explore, and most importantly, continue crafting intricate narratives that captivate your readers’ minds and keep them turning pages well into the night.

Ready to write your balanced mystery?  Enroll in Write A Killer Mystery and get it done. 
Photo by Steve Johnson:

Similar Posts